Olivia Plathmay have been treated unfairly by the Plath family, especially Kim Plath, but she has been a problematicWelcome To Plathvillecast member over the years. Olivia and Ethan Plath married in 2018, and the rise and fall of their relationship has been a focal point of the show, especially as they navigated differences in family life. Olivia was vocal about her struggles with the Plath family’s strict rules, disentangling herself from overly rigid Christianity. However, asWelcome To Plathvilleseason 6unfolds, Olivia has revealed her messy self.
The tension between Olivia, Kim, and Barry Plath continues to be a major storyline. Olivia criticized their parenting style and control over Ethan and his siblings. This conflict led to a temporary estrangement between Ethan and his parents. Eventually, Ethan’s devotion to his family won out, withOlivia and Ethan divorcingbefore the current season ofWelcome To Plathvillebegan airing. Is Olivia a victim, or is she just as problematic as the rest of the Plaths?
1Olivia Condemned Ethan For Wanting A Relationship With His Family
She Wanted Him To Cut Them Off Completely
Olivia consistently expressed frustration and disappointment over Ethan’s desire to maintain a relationship with his family, particularly his parents. In various episodes ofWelcome to Plathville, Olivia condemned Ethan’s attempts to reconcile with Barry and Kim, whom she held responsible for many of their marital issues. While Kim was overly controlling with Ethan,it wasn’t fair for Olivia to push Ethan to cut his parents offfrom his life.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Instead of understanding Ethan’s situation, Olivia accused him of being inconsiderate of her feelings and the trauma she had endured due to his family’s actions. Olivia’s disapproval was evident when she stated that Ethan prioritizing his family over their marriage felt like a betrayal. She frequently reminded him of the emotional manipulation and hostility she had faced from his parents, arguing that by continuing to engage with them, Ethan was disregarding the boundaries they had set as a couple. Because of this, Olivia only made their issues worse.
2Olivia Isolated Ethan
They Moved Far Away From His Family
When Ethan didn’t heed her wishes, Olivia purposefully isolated Ethan from his family. Olivia and Ethan decided to move to Minnesota, distancing themselves from his immediate family in the South. Ethan expressed hope that being away from his family would reduce the negative effects on their marriage, but he might have been bamboozled by Olivia. This move followed years of conflict with the Plath family, particularly with Ethan’s parents and his sister, Moriah Plath, who had a falling out with Olivia and cut off contact with both of them.
Isolating a significant other from their close friends and family is a sign of manipulation, and Olivia definitely did this to Ethan.
Barry and Kim weren’t pleased with Olivia’s actions. She had a contentious relationship with Kim and Barry, who didn’t take their son’s rebellion lying down.Barry accused Olivia of brainwashing Ethan, implying that she influenced him to sever ties with his family. While Olivia may have thought isolating Ethan could have saved their marriage, it didn’t.
3Olivia Alleged Kim Was A Credit Card Scammer
She Changed Ethan’s Passwords
Olivia and Kim’s feud reached a whole new level whenOlivia accused Kim of credit card fraud. While Ethan, Moriah, and Micah Plath were working toward forgiving Kim, Olivia couldn’t bring herself to practice forgiveness. Despite pressure to reconcile, Olivia prioritized her mental health and finally revealed another layer behind their years-long conflict. In theWelcome To Plathvilleseason 4 finale, Olivia shared that she once viewed Kim as a mother figure but was shocked to learn Kim was using Ethan’s credit card without repayment, leaving him in debt.
“I will never forget marrying a 20-year-old man whose mom was using his credit card and buying things for herself and not paying him back.”
WhenOlivia intervened by changing Ethan’s password, Kim lashed out. This incident strained Kim and Olivia’s relationship and highlighted both their manipulative behavior. Instead of confronting Kim directly, she caused more trouble.
4Olivia Didn’t Accept Moriah’s Apology
She Didn’t Find It Specific Enough
Moriah and Olivia have struggled to reconcilesince their explosive blowout, but Moriah seems ready to try. Unfortunately,Olivia won’t accept Moriah’s apology. She explained that Moriah’s apology felt insincere because it wasn’t specific enough. Olivia didn’t feel that Moriah took enough accountability for her actions, but if Olivia really wanted to smooth things over, she’d forgive her and move on.
“I think you’d be really nice for her to be like, ‘Yeah, you know, Ethan told us what actually happened, and I’m sorry I called you a liar in front of the whole world when it was proven to be true.”
Moriah accused Olivia of stealing her music and profiting from it, which turned out to be untrue. Although Moriah admitted her mistake, Olivia felt the apology was more about Moriah’s self-redemption than genuine remorse. Ultimately, Olivia said that the whole experience left her feeling betrayed and that she no longer wanted to engage with the Plath family. However, she continues to do so because she’s messy and problematic.
5Olivia Hard Launched Her Love Interest
His Name Is Brendan
TLCreleased a clip fromWelcome To Plathvillein which Olivia hard launched her new boyfriend, 27-year-old Brendan. While it’s her prerogative to date someone new after leaving Ethan, she seems to be rubbing her happiness in his face and trying to claw for more screen time. Olivia isn’t part of the Plath family anymore, and it’s time to stop featuring her problematic storyline on the show.
“Why did the Phathville show start it off today with Olivia? it’s not the Olivia dating show!!!”
Fans are done with Olivia, as evidenced in the comment section of the post. “I thought we divorced her…” wrote one follower, while another noted, “Why did the Phathville show start it off today with Olivia? it’s not the Olivia dating show!!!” Some of Olivia’s complaints over the years were legitimate, but shoving her new boyfriend in the Plath family’s faces seems to paint her as more of a villain than anything else. If she had any class, she wouldn’t hard launch her new boyfriend on her ex-husband’s family’s reality TV show.
6Olivia Called The Plaths “Not Good People”
She Didn’t Need To Say That
In an Instagram Reel from September 2024,Oliviacalled the Plaths “not good people” in a video raising awareness for suicide prevention. While drinking sparkling water and applying skincare,Olivia proceeded to talk about the Plath family’s negative rolein her life while also denouncing any cyberbullying against them. She seemed to take the high road asWelcome To Plathvilleseason 6 began.
Olivia asking fans to disengage from cyberbulling is a stark reminder that reality TV stars are still real people and deserve respect.
Olivia’s fans were supportive in the comments, saying, “Olivia coming to Micahs gfs defense is says so much about her character” and, “The fact that Olivia spoke not only about herself but the family members who treated her badly speaks volumes to her character and growth because you know they would never do that for her.” Olivia victimizes herself and takes on a holier-than-thou attitude when she should just stay out of situations. While it’s commendable for her to defend the Plaths in the video, she didn’t need to call them terrible people just because they had their differences.
7Olivia Gives Hot Takes On Instagram
She Doesn’t Shy Away From Sharing Her Opinion
Oliviagives hot takes on Instagram regarding the Plaths rather than letting their issues simmer down off screen. In a video from late September 2024, Olivia defended her decision to keep the last name Plath. Everything she’s done in her adult life has been with the last name Plath, and it’s become part of her identity. Olivia shrugged off comments that she should “give her last name back,” but it brings up a wider discussion regarding changing one’s last name, sexism, and identity.
While the more cynical argument forOlivia keeping her married name involves her desperation for fame and notoriety, it’s a struggle many individuals, mostly women, face when getting married and divorced. There’s identity wrapped up in a name, and women are often expected (or willingly choose due to cultural norms) to change their last name. This tradition can evoke societal whiplash when a marriage breaks down, as was the case for Olivia. However, by becoming embroiled in an argument online, Olivia has lived up to her reputation as a pot-stirrer.
8Olivia Hung Out With Micah’s Friends
They Could Be Paid Actors
Despite divorcing Ethan,Olivia was spotted hanging out with Micah’s friends on the show. In a recent episode ofWelcome to Plathville, some of Micah’s friends were present at Olivia’s “sex education party.” While this could indicate that Olivia ran in the same social circles as the Plaths for years, it could be the network that’s acting nefariously. The network might have recycled friends from Micah’s circle or potentially paid actors for the show, though it’s probably both. The unusual nature of this crossover between Olivia and Micah’s social circles definitely raised eyebrows.
Regardless, if Olivia really cared about keeping the peace and healing broken relationships, she would move on. She wouldn’t feel the need to be part of the show anymore. Olivia definitely wouldn’t be hosting provocative parties to get more attention from the show. However, she’s proven over the years that she likes to cause trouble.
9Olivia Refuses To See The Good In The Plaths
She Won’t Forgive Them
Olivia refuses to see any good in the Plath family, which ultimately led to her divorce from Ethan. Olivia has openly criticized Kim, stating that she feels manipulated and controlled by her. While Olivia’s experiences may be valid, she often frames Kim in a negative light without acknowledging any efforts Kim might have made to reconnect or understand her.Olivia tends to view her former mother-in-law as solely controlling, despite some moments where Kim has expressed regret or a desire to mend fences.
Olivia chose to distance herself from the entire Plath family. Instead of maintaining connections with her ex-husband’s siblings or finding common ground, Olivia expressed feelings of betrayal and hurt, rarely highlighting any positive aspects of family members who had tried to bridge the gap, such as Moriah and Micah. In fact, she’s demonized everyone, even as they’ve tried to apologize.
10Olivia Got Called A Narcissist by Barry & Veronica
She Allegedly Pushed Veronica At A Wedding
Veronica Peters is new to the Plath family, but she’s already making a better impression on Barry and Kim than Olivia ever did. After Olivia literally ran into her at a wedding in Minnesota, Veronica made it clear that she didn’t like Olivia, and even viewed her as a narcissist. Barry shares this view, as he alluded to inWelcome To Plathville.
25
Hometown
Boca Raton, Florida
“When we first met, we spent a long time discussing a common experience,” Barry shared in a recent episode of the show. While it seemed pretty obvious he was talking about Olivia, Veronica didn’t mince words. “Olivia’s definitely the narcissist Barry and I were talking about,” she shared.
Olivia might not be a narcissist, but she’s definitely not the angel she’s tried to portray onWelcome To Plathville. The best thing Olivia could do for herself and the Plath family is to fully separate herself from their story. Kim mistreated her for years, and Olivia rightly didn’t stand down. Sometimes, it takes a problematic and messy person to fight someone equally toxic.
Welcome To Plathville
Cast
Welcome to Plathville is a reality television series that follows the lives of the Plath family, a strongly conservative family with nine children that, while sharing some of their values, have begun to yearn for and seize their own independence. As the family tries to hold onto their old-world values, primarily separated from the rest of the country, they will reckon with their children’s newfound beliefs and clash with new family members from their spouses.
