HBO’sHarry Potterremake is in the process ofcasting its Severus Snape and Minerva McGonagall, and Janet McTeer has already proved she’s perfect for the latter role. If McTeer officially signs on to play the head of Gryffindor House in theupcomingHarry Pottershow, she’ll have big shoes to fill afterMaggie Smith’s performance as Professor McGonagall. Fortunately, McTeer would bring decades of acting experience to the table, including stints on three popular shows that perfectly prepare her to play the iconicHarry Pottercharacter.
McGonagall is among the most important adult characters at Hogwarts after Albus Dumbledore and Severus Snape, and she’s someone who requires a delicate balancing act to get right. Smith managed to walk the line between the two sides of McGonagall’s personality impressively, highlighting why she was perfect for theHarry Potterrole.McTeer will also need to master the character’s dualityif she hopes to deliver a faithful portrayal of her. Fortunately, she’s already shown she’s capable of it.
There’s 1 Professor McGonagall Balance The Harry Potter Remake’s Actor Needs To Nail
The Character Must Have An Intimidating Side & A More Compassionate One
ManyHarry Pottercharacters can be broken down to one prominent trait, butMcGonagall has two distinct sides to her: the stern, strict Hogwarts professor and the kinder, more compassionate mentor. Part of the reason McGonagall is so lovable in the books is because she balances both of these personas well, bringing each of them out at exactly the right time. The more intimidating version of McGonagall shows why she’s such a well-respected and powerful witch, while the softer side of her character makes her all the more endearing to students and readers.
Janet McTeer vs Maggie Smith: How HBO’s Rumored McGonagall Compares To The Harry Potter Movies
Janet McTeer is reportedly being eyed to play Professor McGonagall in the Harry Potter remake, but how would her character compare to Maggie Smith’s?
Smith knew how to juggle both qualities on-screen, ensuring that theHarry Pottermovies' take on McGonagall fit with her book description — and that she landed well with viewers. Some of the star’s best moments as McGonagall involved well-timed jokes or heartfelt interactions with her students. However, when it came down to it, Smith’s take on the character could put up a fierce fight against Death Eaters, something she proved during the Battle of Hogwarts inHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.
Given that this balancing act is true to McGonagall’s character in theHarry Potterbooks, McTeer will need to master it just as well as Smith.
Given that this balancing act is true to McGonagall’s character intheHarry Potterbooks, McTeer will need to master it just as well as Smith. The odds are in her favor though, asshe has played characters who exhibit McGonagall’s most important qualities in previous projects. That will make it easier to slip into the two sides of her character in the upcomingHarry Potterremake.
Janet McTeer’s Ozark & Kaos Roles Prove She Can Handle McGonagall’s Intimidating Side
Helen Pierce & Hera Prepared Her To Play The Harry Potter Professor
McTeer has many great roles under her belt, but two of her recent TV series stand out ahead of her potentialHarry Pottercasting: Netflix’sOzark and Kaos.InOzark, McTeertook on the role of Helen Pierce, an accomplished lawyer who works for the Navarro drug cartel. As you might imagine, this position pushes her to be extremely competent and ruthless. She’s someone who can work with people like the Byrdes, but she’s also there to intimidate them. She’s charming but stern, and she’ll do anything for her daughter. Strangely enough,this all sets her up to succeed as McGonagall.
Although both Helen Pierce and Hera are both more ruthless than McGonagall, the characters do prove that McTeer can be formidable.
McTeer’sKaosrole boasts similar energy to herOzarkone, as she plays Hera in Netflix’s one-season Greek mythology satire. Although she’s forced to deal with the whims and outbursts of Jeff Goldblum’s Zeus, Hera is fierce, commanding, and confident — all traits that McTeer’s McGonagall could benefit from. Although both Helen Pierce and Hera are both more ruthless than McGonagall, the characters do prove that McTeer can be formidable. And since she can’t swing completely in that direction, it’s a good thingJessica Jonesshowed her ability to balance that with compassion.
Jessica Jones Shows Janet McTeer Can Capture Both Parts Of McGonagall’s Personality
The Netflix Series Proves She Can Swing Between Extremes, Too
McTeer played the titular character’s mother, Alisa, in Netflix’sJessica Jones,and the role is another worthy addition to her lineup. Like McTeer’sOzarkandKaoscharacters, Alisa is a complex figure who requires a careful approach. Alisa continues McTeer’s trend of embodying formidable female characters, but she also has a kinder side that comes out at times. McTeer even discussed this detail of the character withTheWrap, noting, “You need somebody who can look like they’re really scary and terrifying, but someone who can also be more complicated, softer, more motherly.”
HBO’s Harry Potter Remake Embracing A Hogwarts Professor Headcanon Would Make 1 Scene So Much More Heartbreaking
Most popular Harry Potter headcanons are best left to fans' minds, but there is one in particular that would be a valuable addition to HBO’s remake.
While McGonagall shouldn’t necessarily be scary,itisimportant that McTeer can tackle her character’s more compassionate and nurturing moments. And the fact that she’s gone back and forth between the two extremes inJessica Jonesbodes well for her potentialHarry Pottercasting. After all, she’ll need to switch each side on and off depending on what McGonagall is doing and whom she’s interacting with. Although the Golden Trio is the central focus of the story, getting characters like McGonagall wrong could make or break the show.
Why Getting This Balancing Act Right Is So Important For The Harry Potter Show
There’s A Lot Of Pressure On The HBO Remake’s New Cast
It’s a relief that McTeer is capable of the balancing act that McGonagall requires in theHarry Potterremake, asgetting the characters right will be crucial to the series' success. One of theharshest realities about HBO’sHarry Pottershowis that it will inevitably be compared to the original adaptations. And if there’s one thing the movies get right, it’s the casting and character portrayals. Many of the original stars are now the faces associated with their characters, and it will be difficult for even the best talent to live up to expectations.
HBO’s Harry Potter Remake Will Surely Fix Two Of The Movies' Biggest Mistakes - But Not For Another 10 Years
HBO’s Harry Potter TV series has the chance to fix mistakes made by the film franchise, yet one big oversight won’t be redone for another ten years.
Add in the other challenges that the HBO show faces — like ensuring a story that’s faithful enough to please book fans but different enough to stand out from the movies — and it really can’t afford to take risks that could alienate viewers. Poorly casting certain characters or portraying them too differently from their book counterparts would be one such risk. So, the TV show must aim high while looking for talent. Fortunately,the experience of actors like McTeer, Paapa Essiedu, and John Lithgow suggests it’s doing just that.
HBO’sHarry Potterremake is expected to premiere in 2026.
And with stars like McTeer not just having impressive acting backgrounds, but also prior roles relevant to their potentialHarry Pottercharacters, fans can rest knowing that the remake is taking the right approach. Hopefully, these casting rumors are confirmed soon, with McTeer and Essiedu joining Lithgow as actors officially associated with the show. It will be a relief to know that the remake will do justice to some of the series' most prominent adult characters.
